Files
openclaw-control-plane/handoff/CORRECTION.md
2026-05-19 16:30:40 +08:00

9.9 KiB

CORRECTION Handoff

Role

Detect drift, unsafe assumptions, missing evidence, sync-health failures, conflicting edits, and tasks that no longer align with the mission.

Watchlist

  • Agents editing outside their role scope.
  • Executors marking their own work as accepted.
  • Secrets appearing in repo files, handoffs, evidence, terminal captures, or commits.
  • Any attempt to alter the frozen smartmotor.cloud website, homepage-linked content, static assets, Nginx routing, bind mounts, container images, /opt/services/docker-compose.openclaw.yml, or any equivalent compose/service entries that affect public website output.
  • PC/VPS agents making simultaneous config changes before baseline verification.
  • Gitea sync conflicts in AGENT_BOARD.md or handoff files.
  • Stale or missing heartbeat files under sync-state/.
  • Any sync-state/error-*.md file.
  • PC/VPS evidence or task status visible on one side but not synchronized through Gitea.
  • Changes to Nginx, Docker, or Windows services without rollback notes.

Sync Health Policy

  • Warning: peer heartbeat older than 2 minutes.
  • Blocked: peer heartbeat older than 5 minutes.
  • Blocked: any sync error file exists.
  • Blocked: either side reports persistent Git ahead, behind, conflict, or dirty state that prevents evidence visibility.
  • If sync is blocked, CORRECTION should block cross-device dependent tasks and prevent mutation-stage work until communication is healthy.

Current State

  • 2026-05-19 16:29 UTC+8: Fresh T13 G2 correction guard check completed in CORRECTION role from D:\openclaw-control-plane after git pull reported already up to date.
  • G2 remains user-authorized and AGENT_BOARD.md shows G2 In Progress.
  • T13 remains ready and owned by CORRECTION.
  • T9 is blocked; it must remain blocked until ORCHESTRATOR reviews this fresh PASS and explicitly releases T9.
  • T10 is blocked; it must remain blocked until T9 produces one matching non-secret pairing request ID or pending node ID.
  • PC heartbeat is present, fresh, and clean: 2026-05-19T16:28:36+08:00.
  • VPS heartbeat is present, fresh, and clean: 2026-05-19T16:29:05+0800.
  • No sync-state/error-*.md files are present.
  • Current evidence directory contains only baseline and baseline-verifier evidence. The earlier evidence/pc-g2-node-run-20260519.md was deleted by a later PC sync commit, so no current G2 node-run evidence exists.
  • Rollback note rollback/pc-g2-node-run-20260519.md exists, but T9 states openclaw node run was not executed because the token was not available in the same non-persistent local shell session.
  • Secret scan found only documented placeholders and policy references, not exposed secret values.
  • No current role-misdirection, frozen website risk, service persistence, openclaw node install/start, Nginx/Docker/website change, firewall/network change, VPS approval, node start, or configuration mutation risk was found in tracked control-plane state.
  • Fresh guard decision: PASS for sync/secret/role/freeze/config checks. This PASS does not unblock T9 by itself; ORCHESTRATOR must explicitly release T9 based on the PASS.
  • 2026-05-19 14:50 UTC+8: G2 pre-flight guard check completed in CORRECTION role from D:\openclaw-control-plane after git pull fast-forwarded only sync-state/heartbeat-vps.json.
  • Requested tasks/T13-G2-preflight-guard.md does not exist; actual T13 guard file is tasks/T13-G2-correction-guard.md.
  • G2 is authorized and AGENT_BOARD.md shows G2 In Progress.
  • T13 is ready and owned by CORRECTION.
  • T9 is ready; T10 remains blocked until T9 produces one matching non-secret pairing request ID or pending node ID.
  • PC heartbeat is present, fresh, and clean: 2026-05-19T14:51:14+08:00.
  • VPS heartbeat is present, fresh, and clean: 2026-05-19T14:51:04+0800.
  • No sync-state/error-*.md files are present.
  • Secret scan found only documented placeholders and policy references, not exposed secret values.
  • Role-misdirection risk is currently cleared by ORCHESTRATOR's recovery and fresh second authorization; keep monitoring for new role/workspace mismatch.
  • No current evidence of frozen website risk, service persistence, openclaw node install/start, Nginx/Docker/website change, firewall/network change, VPS approval, node start, or other configuration mutation.
  • Pre-flight decision: pass. CORRECTION does not execute PC/VPS commands; T13 guard may continue and T9 may proceed only under docs/G2_RUNBOOK.md.
  • 2026-05-19 12:37 UTC+8: Fresh second G2 authorization was received by ORCHESTRATOR in the correct target window/workspace.
  • Sync-health was healthy by tracked files at authorization time: PC and VPS heartbeats were clean, and no sync-state/error-*.md files were observed.
  • Corrected G2 state after second authorization: T13 and T9 are ready; T10 remains blocked until T9 produces a matching non-secret pairing request ID or pending node ID.
  • Continue blocking service persistence, openclaw node install/start, Nginx/Docker/website changes, firewall/network changes, public port exposure, G3/G4 actions, and any token/secret recording.
  • 2026-05-19 12:22 UTC+8: Audited role-misdirection event after git pull reported the repo was already up to date.
  • Background under review: prompts intended for ORCHESTRATOR were mistakenly sent to VPS_VERIFIER during the recent hour.
  • Recent git history shows VPS-origin commits modified files outside VPS_VERIFIER's allowed write scope:
    • 1400aea modified AGENT_BOARD.md and USER_STATUS.md.
    • 588db23 modified handoff/ORCHESTRATOR.md, tasks/T9-G2-PC-node-run.md, tasks/T10-G2-VPS-pairing-approve.md, and tasks/T13-G2-correction-guard.md.
    • 5134f68 modified handoff/CORRECTION.md, handoff/PC_EXECUTOR.md, handoff/VPS_EXECUTOR.md, and tasks/T7-correction-monitor.md.
  • These file changes align with ORCHESTRATOR/COACH/CORRECTION/executor handoff responsibilities, not VPS_VERIFIER responsibilities. Treat this as a role-scope incident requiring ORCHESTRATOR review and adoption or correction.
  • handoff/VPS_VERIFIER.md now self-reports that VPS_VERIFIER modified only evidence/verify-vps-baseline-20260515.md and handoff/VPS_VERIFIER.md; that self-report is inconsistent with the VPS-origin commits above if those commits were produced by the misdirected VPS_VERIFIER session.
  • No rollback was performed.
  • No evidence was found that VPS_VERIFIER executed live G2 approval, nodes pending, devices approve, nodes approve, service restart/reload, token rotation, Gateway config mutation, Nginx/Docker/compose/bind-mount/image change, or frozen website content/routing changes during the misdirection window.
  • Read-only VPS baseline verification evidence remains consistent with T6 scope: Docker/Gateway/Nginx/HTTPS/CLI --help checks only; no approval except --help checks.
  • Evidence directory currently contains only baseline and baseline-verifier evidence; no pc-g2-*, vps-g2-*, or G2 approval evidence exists.
  • rollback/ contains no G2 rollback notes, so no G2 token/run/approval action should be treated as having begun.
  • Secret scan of evidence found no likely secret values; current tracked text contains policy, negative, and placeholder references only.
  • Sync-health is currently healthy by tracked files: both heartbeat files exist, are fresh for this audit window, and no sync-state/error-*.md files are present.
  • Correction decision: block G2 progression until ORCHESTRATOR explicitly reviews the role-scope incident, reclaims ownership of ORCHESTRATOR-owned files and status changes, and restates the authorized next step.

Next Actions

  1. Ask ORCHESTRATOR to review this fresh PASS and decide whether to release T9 from blocked.
  2. Monitor T13 for sync-health, secret, role/workspace, pairing-identity, and freeze-policy stop conditions.
  3. Keep T9 blocked until ORCHESTRATOR explicitly releases it based on this fresh PASS.
  4. Keep T10 blocked until T9 evidence includes one matching non-secret pairing request ID or pending node ID.
  5. VPS_VERIFIER should remain limited to VPS verification evidence and handoff/VPS_VERIFIER.md unless explicitly reassigned.
  6. Continue forbidding service persistence, openclaw node install/start, Nginx/Docker/website changes, firewall/network changes, public port exposure, G3/G4 actions, and any token/secret recording.
  7. If new sync-state/error-*.md files appear or heartbeat freshness exceeds policy thresholds, record a separate sync-health blocker.

Last Update

2026-05-19 16:29 UTC+8 - Fresh T13 guard check passed for sync/secret/role/freeze/config risks. T9 remains blocked pending ORCHESTRATOR release based on this PASS; T10 remains blocked pending one matching non-secret pairing request/node ID from T9.

2026-05-19 14:50 UTC+8 - G2 pre-flight guard check passed for CORRECTION/T13. Sync-health is fresh and clean, no sync error files or secret leak were found, T9 remains ready, and T10 remains blocked pending one matching non-secret pairing request/node ID from T9.

2026-05-19 12:37 UTC+8 - Fresh second G2 authorization received in correct ORCHESTRATOR workspace. T13/T9 may proceed under runbook; T10 remains blocked pending T9 evidence. No PC/VPS command was executed by ORCHESTRATOR.

2026-05-19 12:22 UTC+8 - Role-misdirection audit found cross-role file modifications from VPS-origin commits and requires ORCHESTRATOR takeover before G2 proceeds. No secret leak or VPS service/Nginx/Docker/website mutation was detected.

2026-05-19 12:16 UTC+8: G2 authorization guard update.

  • User authorized G2 only for foreground PC node run and corresponding VPS pairing approval under docs/G2_RUNBOOK.md.
  • T9 and T13 are ready; T10 remains draft until T9 produces a matching non-secret pairing request ID or pending node ID.
  • Continue blocking service persistence, openclaw node install/start, Nginx/Docker/website changes, firewall/network changes, public port exposure, and any token/secret recording.
  • Stop G2 if heartbeat becomes stale, any sync-state/error-*.md appears, evidence is not visible on both sides, request identity is ambiguous, or freeze compliance becomes uncertain.